11-25-2014, 04:16 PM
Quote:Well, I'd argue that in the "post-cream-and-clear" era, ages 31-34 are squarely not peak years.
If you take away his half-season of wonderment that was 2013 (yes, I'm slightly cherry-picking), Ramirez's stats from 2011 on aren't all that different from Cespedes. All things being equal, of course I'd rather have Ramirez. However, considering his recent injury history, I'd go so far as to say that the Red Sox having Ramirez on the roster in two years will hurt them more than not having Cespedes.
I would agree with your analysis if the subject were Sandoval, but not so for Ramirez. Ramirez will be great in Fenway Park. His line drive contact is perfect for that field. Coming from Dodger Stadium to Fenway will look a lot like Beltre coming from Safeco to Fenway several years before. I love that signing for the Red Sox and I'm surprised it only took a 4 year commitment.
And in regards to peak years, your point is taken. What I should have said is the contract ends prior to his skills completely falling off - like the A-Rod, Pujols and Hamilton deals.